Penn Carey Law professor Leo Katz explains how the selection effect and judicial strategy can make merit-based rulings look indistinguishable from politically motivated or random decisions.
2 min. read
The Journal of Legal Studies has published a new article by Leo Katz, Frank Carano Professor of Law at the University of Pennsylvania, co-authored with Alvaro Sandroni of Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management. In “The Judging Game,” Katz and Sandroni develop a game-theoretic model that helps explain why judicial decisions often appear either politically motivated or arbitrary—even in legal systems staffed by rational, competent, and largely impartial judges.
The authors argue that this appearance is the natural result of the selection effect—the tendency for cases with clear outcomes to settle out of court—combined with judges’ rational response to that fact. Litigants tend to settle “easy” cases to minimize litigation costs, meaning that judges mostly decide complex, evenly balanced cases. Under the right conditions, this dynamic makes judges’ decisions observationally indistinguishable from decisions based on political bias or even a coin toss.
“We show that because of the selection effect, a judicial system with competent, motivated, mostly impartial judges will produce decisions that are indistinguishable from decisions based on politics or a coin flip,” says Katz. “They look lawless, but they aren’t. The selection effect that ensures that mostly hard cases proceed to appeal just make it look that way. This is actually good news.”
Nanoparticle blueprints reveal path to smarter medicines
New research involving Penn Engineering shows detailed variation in lipid nanoparticle size, shape, and internal structure, and finds that such factors correlate with how well they deliver therapeutic cargo to a particular destination.
A generous gift from alumni Glenn and Amanda Fuhrman brings the work of internationally acclaimed artist Jaume Plensa to the University of Pennsylvania. The latest addition to the Penn Art Collection expands Philadelphia's public art.
A massive chunk of ice, a new laser, and new information on sea-level rise
For nearly a decade, Leigh Stearns and collaborators aimed a laser scanner system at Greenland’s Helheim Glacier. Their long-running survey reveals that Helheim’s massive calving events don’t behave the way scientists once thought, reframing how ice loss contributes to sea-level rise.
