Alongside Nursing Dean Antonia M. Villarruel, Penn President Amy Gutmann and PIK Professor Jonathan Moreno discussed their new book “Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven but Nobody Wants to Die” at the Smilow Center for Translational Research.
Jonathan Moreno, a professor of medical ethics and the history and sociology of science, and Amy Gutmann, a moral and political philosopher, chat with School of Nursing Dean Antonia M. Villarruel for a book talk on campus.
“And it is, in fact, everybody’s business to weigh in on those controversies,” writes Gutmann, a moral and political philosopher, and Moreno, a professor of medical ethics and the history and sociology of science.
Such is an example of the meshing of political science and bioethics, two fields of particular interest to Isabel Perera, a fellow in the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy, who earned her doctorate in political science from Penn last year.
“When discussing how to build an ethical health care system,” Perera said, “bioethics and political science can come together and offer something productive for policy, and also for practice.”
The trio took a deep dive into “Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven but Nobody Wants to Die.” Most attendees were students, faculty, and staff with interests in medicine and bioethics.
Perera was chatting at a reception at the Smilow Center for Translational Research after an hourlong book talk that featured Gutmann and Moreno, with moderator Antonia M. Villarruel, the Margaret Bond Simon Dean of Nursing. Steven Joffe, the interim chair of and professor in Medical Ethics and Health Policy, offered introductory remarks. Most attendees of the Tuesday afternoon event were students, faculty, and staff with interests and experiences in medicine and bioethics, providing the co-authors a chance to dive a bit deeper into their book’s details than they’ve been able to with more general audiences.
“I often say that if you pull up any health or science story in the newspaper [or on TV], there’s almost always a bioethics angle to it, and often it’s the bioethics angle in those stories that make them so interesting,” Joffe said. “It’s really very topical and timely.”
Gutmann, Moreno, and Villarruel’s conversation flowed freely, covering issues including how medical ethics came of age; their own, personal family stories related to bioethics; access to affordable health care; and how doctors have, over time, been taken off their “pedestals.”
“When I was in high school, I asked my father what I should do and he said, ‘Well, you should go to medical school because doctors have the most influence,’” said Moreno. “That was the mid-1960s, and I don’t think any physicians in this room would feel that way today. It’s just incredible how that’s changed.”
Moreno served as a senior adviser of President Barack Obama’s Bioethics Commission while Gutmann was chair.
A good change, indeed, Gutmann noted, as this shift has allowed for a patient-centric movement.
“Since we are at Penn, it really is important to see how this parallels our ethos of collaboration across boundaries,” Gutmann said. “There is only ethical health care when there can be a dialogue between nurses, doctors, patients, and other caregivers and family.”
They also discussed the rules and guardrails that have been put in place, such as requirements for obtaining informed consent and special protections for vulnerable people, to protect individuals who volunteer for research studies and heighten trust in medical professionals and their research.
Gutmann explained how clinical trials today—in which we “dot every ‘i’ and cross every ‘t’”—are saving lives, like Emily Whitehead’s, who benefited from Carl June and his Penn Medicine team’s engineered T-cell therapy.
“When science partners with ethics, great things can come,” said Gutmann. “To have Emily Whitehead, who was on her deathbed at 7 years old now cancer free at 14 years old … that has saved now thousands of lives and will continue to save more and more in different areas.”
That is why I think bioethics is so important, because it’s part and parcel of how we do medical science to surge it forward.
Penn President Amy Gutmann
Gutmann continued, “That is why I think bioethics is so important, because it’s part and parcel of how we do medical science to surge it forward. Some people have written about bioethics as if it’s a break, that it’s stopping medical progress. That couldn’t be any more wrong. It is part of the fuel that makes medical progress, progress.”
Gutmann and Moreno, who worked together on President Barack Obama’s Bioethics Commission (Gutmann was chair and Moreno was a senior adviser), also discussed nudging for good, moral distress affecting doctors and nurses, “Medicare for more,” and the ultimate impact they hope their book, released in August, makes: to help folks prepare for the difficult conversations and decisions related to health care they’ll inevitably face.
Three questions from the audience concluded the event, with one from Edward Rodriguez Caceres, a senior in the Biological Basis of Behavior Program, who asked Gutmann how her responsibility of the University of Pennsylvania Health System, alongside J. Larry Jameson, Penn’s Executive Vice President for the Health System and Dean of the Perelman School of Medicine, and Health System CEO Kevin B. Mahoney, has influenced her views on the ethics of health care.
Edward Rodriguez Caceres, with Gutmann. Rodriguez, a senior in the Biological Basis of Behavior Program, hopes to get his master’s in bioethics and, someday, his medical degree.
Gutmann, clearly passionate about the question, said even though she’s taught and written about bioethics for decades, such a leadership role has profoundly influenced her, specifically as it pertains to an even more engaged understanding of the importance of bringing basic research to the patient, as well as ensuring the very best health care is made more accessible to all.
Rodriguez, who hopes to get his master’s in bioethics at Penn, and someday become a medical doctor, was encouraged by the talk. “It’s made me hopeful for the future,” he said.
“The title of the book might seem like it’s for a specific audience, but it really isn’t,” Rodriguez said. “It’s for everyone. It’s something that fits into everyone’s life.”
Perera noted a similar sentiment: “Bioethics touches everyone’s life at some point, even in ways you might not even realize.”
“It can really be a life or death conversation,” she said.
Nanoparticle blueprints reveal path to smarter medicines
New research involving Penn Engineering shows detailed variation in lipid nanoparticle size, shape, and internal structure, and finds that such factors correlate with how well they deliver therapeutic cargo to a particular destination.
A generous gift from alumni Glenn and Amanda Fuhrman brings the work of internationally acclaimed artist Jaume Plensa to the University of Pennsylvania. The latest addition to the Penn Art Collection expands Philadelphia's public art.
A massive chunk of ice, a new laser, and new information on sea-level rise
For nearly a decade, Leigh Stearns and collaborators aimed a laser scanner system at Greenland’s Helheim Glacier. Their long-running survey reveals that Helheim’s massive calving events don’t behave the way scientists once thought, reframing how ice loss contributes to sea-level rise.
